Sports
Picks & Odds
Betting Guide
Casinos
Gambling is prohibited for underage individuals | Commercial content | Regional restrictions may apply | T&Cs apply | Play responsibly

Colorado Rockies vs. New York Yankees Preview, Odds & Predictions – Friday, May 23, 2025

Mohsin Baldiwala

Tanner Gordon vs Clarke Schmidt

Baseball / MLB
24/05/2025 – 01:40
Colorado Rockies
VS
01:40
24/05/2025
New York Yankees
Odds updated on May 23, 2025 at 4:35 pm

The Yankees are rolling. Winners of eight of their last ten, and fresh off a sweep of the Rangers, New York heads west with momentum and odds in their favour, a firm grip on the AL East, and a chance to keep building against a team going in the opposite direction. What are your predictions?

The Colorado Rockies, meanwhile, are in the midst of a nightmarish season. At 8-42, they own the worst record in baseball by a mile and are currently on pace for one of the lowest win totals in MLB history. On Friday, the Rockies will host a three-game set at Coors Field, though the Yankees could be vulnerable early after a quick turnaround following Thursday’s matinee in the Bronx.

Rockies vs. Yankees Preview

Clarke Schmidt will get the ball for New York in the opener. While the Yankees’ rotation has been among the best in baseball after a topsy-turvy and unreliable start, Clarke Schmidt has struggled to find rhythm since his return from the IL and enters with something to prove. Colorado will counter with right-hander Tanner Gordon, who is making just his second major league appearance. Gordon allowed seven runs (four earned) over 6.1 innings in his May 8 debut and steps in for Chase Dollander, who was recently sidelined with forearm tightness.

ALSO READ: 974 Days Later, the Yankees Finally Walk It Off With a Home Run

Notably, Coors Field is the only active MLB ballpark Aaron Judge has yet to play in during his big league career.

Rockies vs. Yankees Betting Odds

According to BetMGM, the Yankees are obvious favorites at Coors Field.

  • Yankees odds to win: -325
  • Rockies odds to win: +270
  • Spread: Yankees -2.5
  • Total: 12.5
TeamSpreadTotal (8.5)Money Line
Yankees-2.5 (-170)Over 12.5 (-102)-325
Rockies+2.5 (+140)Under 12.5 (-118)+270
Get up 1,500$ back in bonus bet if your first bet doesn’t win !
Click to copy code
COPIED
TPOMLB
Claim $1,500
21+. AZ/CO/IL/IN/IA/KS/LA/MD/MA/MI/NJ/OH/PA/TN/ VA/WV/WY only. Offer not available in DC/MS/NV/NY/PR. New customers only. Qualifying deposit (min $10) and first real money wager required. If qualifying bet settles as a loss, user is refunded 100% in non-withdrawable bonus bets up to $1,500. Full T&Cs can be found on betmgm.com.

Rockies vs. Yankees Predictions

The Yankees are heavy favorites with a -2.5 spread, suggesting oddsmakers expect them to win by at least three runs. The total is set at a high 12.5, which aligns with Coors Field’s reputation for high-scoring games and the Rockies’ weak pitching staff. The Over being nearly even at -102 indicates bookmakers see a realistic path to a slugfest, likely driven by the Yankees’ presently red-hot lineup. It may just be a very lopsided battle at Coors Field.

Score prediction: Yankees 9, Rockies 4
Total prediction: Over 12.5

Win probabilities:

Rockies: ~24%
Yankees: ~76%


mlb mlb

Mohsin Baldiwala is a Master’s student in Journalism and freelance content producer who got hooked on baseball through Seinfeld’s hapless George Costanza. The same reason why he’s a Yankees fan. He writes about sports because he believes it can offer a brief escape from the world’s chaos. Even if that means enduring the heartbreak of the 2024 World Series.

Read more